After 11 years of bringing Bruce Springsteen fans together, Julie and Howie Chaz gave the members of their Facebook group one last thing to do: save the photos and memories they wanted to keep. The founders announced plans to archive Spring-Nuts, a private group that had grown to more than 18,000 members. They said political disagreements had turned into personal attacks and bullying, and Springsteen’s endorsement of Michigan Senate candidate Abdul El-Sayed was the breaking point. What made the announcement especially painful was that the couple still loved the music that had brought everyone there in the first place. sfchronicle.com
![]()
Spring-Nuts had become something bigger than a place to talk about the latest set list. Members gathered in person, and the community raised money for charities. Its events featured members of the E Street Band, and Springsteen himself sent a message to the group during a 2022 gathering at the Stone Pony in Asbury Park. For fans who knew each other first by a name on a screen, those gatherings offered a chance to put faces to names. By the time the founders asked people to save their photos, the group held years of memories that belonged to the members as much as to the artist they’d come to celebrate. sfchronicle.com

For years, the founders tried to keep that space welcoming with a straightforward rule: no politics. As Springsteen became more outspoken, though, the rule became harder to apply. If the artist at the center of the group made a public statement, how could the people who followed him discuss what he was doing without discussing what he’d said? The moderators eventually allowed conversations about Springsteen’s own political remarks. The Chazes said disagreements increasingly turned personal, and some members were made to feel that being a Springsteen fan required agreeing with him. sfchronicle.com

The tension came to a head after Springsteen endorsed El-Sayed on November 2, shortly before the Democrat won Michigan’s Senate race. The Chazes said the endorsement was deeply disappointing to them, citing concerns they had as Jewish fans about some of the candidate’s past remarks and associations. They also said Springsteen had every right to make his choice and that they didn’t hold him responsible for how individual fans treated one another. In their telling, the endorsement brought a longstanding problem into focus: a group that once had room for people with different views had become a place where some felt they had to defend their right to belong. sfchronicle.com

The goodbye applies to the Facebook group as members have known it. The founders have said they plan to continue their annual events and podcast under a different name, with a wider focus on music and charity. That gives the friendships and fundraising something to carry forward, even as the group itself prepares to close. The distinction matters to anyone who has watched an online community become part of their daily life. An event on the calendar gives people somewhere to meet again. It can’t quite recreate the familiar place they used to drop into after a concert, when they were still wide awake and wanted to talk about what they’d just heard. sfchronicle.com
There’s something fitting about the founders giving members time to save their memories before the archive. A photo from a fan gathering might bring back the song someone waited all night to hear, or the friend they finally met after years of talking about it online. The arguments are part of how Spring-Nuts ended. Those pictures tell the story of why people kept coming back for 11 years, and why, even after the group closes, a few familiar faces may still be the first ones they look for when the house lights go down.